Skip to Main Content

What If the Police Report Gets My Car Accident Wrong?


A police report can provide valuable information about a car accident, but police officers do not always get every detail right. An officer may record the wrong vehicle information, misunderstand a witness statement, overlook an injury, or incorrectly describe how the collision occurred.

If the police report gets your car accident wrong in Washington, you may be able to request a correction or have additional information added to the report. Even if the investigating officer refuses to make changes, you can still present evidence to challenge the findings and pursue compensation for your injuries.

The Role of Police Reports in Washington Car Accident Claims

Police officers responding to a collision document information that may help insurance companies determine what happened. However, officers often arrive after the crash and must rely on statements, physical evidence, and their observations to piece together the events.

A Washington police collision report may include:

  • The date, time, and location of the accident.
  • Weather, lighting, and roadway conditions.
  • Driver, passenger, and witness information.
  • Vehicle descriptions and insurance information.
  • Statements from the people involved.
  • Accident diagrams and descriptions of vehicle damage.
  • Reported or observed injuries.
  • Traffic citations and suspected contributing factors.
  • Officer observations and conclusions about the collision.

Insurance adjusters often review police reports when investigating claims. Incorrect information could influence an adjuster’s decision about fault, resulting in reduced compensation or a denied claim.

Common Errors in Car Accident Police Reports

Not every mistake in an accident report carries the same weight. Some errors involve basic information that can easily be verified, while others concern conflicting accounts or an officer’s understanding of the collision.

Factual and Clerical Errors

Factual errors involve information that can usually be confirmed through official documents or other reliable evidence. These mistakes may be easier to correct because they do not necessarily require an officer to reconsider how the accident happened.

Examples include incorrect license plate numbers, misspelled names, inaccurate insurance information, the wrong accident location, or missing passenger details. Providing a driver’s license, vehicle registration, or insurance card may help establish the correct information.

Disputed Statements and Incorrect Fault Determinations

Correcting disputed information can be more difficult. An officer may incorrectly describe which driver entered an intersection first, who changed lanes, or whether a vehicle stopped at a red light.

There is also a difference between an officer incorrectly recording a witness statement and a witness providing an inaccurate account. Police may not remove a statement simply because another person disagrees with it. Independent evidence may be needed to challenge that version of events.

For example, if another driver claims you made an unsafe lane change on I-405 near Bellevue, dashcam footage showing that the other vehicle entered your lane could help challenge the report.

Steps to Correct a Police Accident Report in Washington

If you discover incorrect information in your accident report, address it as soon as possible. Surveillance recordings can be overwritten, witnesses may become difficult to contact, and physical evidence can disappear.

The following steps may help you request a correction:

  1. Obtain a copy of the report. You can request collision records through the Washington State Patrol or contact the investigating law enforcement agency for assistance.
  2. Identify the specific errors. Review the report carefully and note which statements, diagrams, or details are inaccurate.
  3. Gather supporting evidence. Collect documents, photographs, recordings, or other information that demonstrates the mistake.
  4. Contact the investigating agency. Provide the collision report number and ask about its procedures for requesting corrections.
  5. Submit a written explanation. Clearly describe the incorrect information and explain how your evidence supports the requested change.
  6. Request a copy of any updated report. If a correction or supplement is issued, retain a copy and provide it to your insurance company or attorney.

Police department procedures may vary, and submitting a request does not guarantee that the report will be changed. The officer may need to review additional evidence or conduct further investigation before deciding whether a correction is appropriate.

Evidence That Can Help Correct an Accident Report

The stronger your supporting evidence, the easier it may be to demonstrate that the police report contains inaccurate information.

Depending on the circumstances, useful evidence may include:

  • Dashcam footage and nearby security camera recordings.
  • Photographs of vehicle damage, skid marks, and debris.
  • Statements from independent eyewitnesses.
  • Police body camera footage.
  • Vehicle registration and insurance documents.
  • Medical records and injury diagnoses.
  • Vehicle event data recorder information, sometimes called black box data.
  • Cellphone records relevant to distracted driving allegations.
  • Findings from accident reconstruction specialists.

Different types of evidence serve different purposes. Vehicle registration documents may establish a factual mistake, while surveillance footage could contradict an officer’s description of how the collision occurred.

Supplemental Police Reports in Washington

If an officer declines to change the original accident report, you may be able to request a supplemental report. Sometimes called an addendum, this additional documentation can record information that was unavailable during the initial investigation.

For example, a witness may come forward several days after a collision on Bellevue Way and provide information that contradicts another driver’s statement. The investigating officer may document the new witness account in a supplemental report.

A supplemental report does not necessarily replace the original report or reverse an officer’s conclusions. However, it may provide insurance companies and other parties with a more complete record of the accident.

Police Reports Do Not Automatically Determine Car Accident Fault

An unfavorable police report does not automatically mean you are legally responsible for a car accident. Police officers, insurance companies, and courts have different roles when evaluating a collision.

Police officers document the accident and may issue traffic citations. Insurance companies conduct their own investigations and determine whether their policies cover the losses. If a liability dispute results in a lawsuit, a judge or jury may evaluate the evidence and determine legal responsibility.

Speeding, distracted driving, tailgating, impaired driving, failure to yield, and unsafe lane changes may all contribute to a collision. However, receiving a traffic citation does not automatically establish civil liability, just as the absence of a citation does not prove that a driver acted responsibly.

Police reports are also subject to rules governing what evidence may be used in court. Not every statement or conclusion contained in an accident report is automatically admissible at trial.

Washington’s Comparative Fault Rules

Washington follows a pure comparative fault system under RCW 4.22.005. This means you may still recover compensation if you were partly responsible for an accident, although your recovery is reduced according to your percentage of fault.

For example, if your accident-related damages total $50,000 and you are found 20% responsible, your potential recovery would be reduced to $40,000 before other applicable adjustments.

Responsibility can also be divided among multiple parties. In a chain-reaction collision on I-90, several drivers may have contributed to the crash. An inaccurate police report could overlook another driver’s negligence or incorrectly assign a greater percentage of responsibility to you.

Challenging an Insurance Company’s Fault Determination

If an insurance company blames you for a collision based on an inaccurate police report, you can challenge its findings. You do not necessarily need to wait for the police to amend the report before presenting your own evidence.

Request an explanation of how the insurance adjuster determined fault and provide documentation that contradicts inaccurate information. If you obtain a corrected or supplemental report, submit it to the adjuster and request that your claim be reconsidered.

You should also continue documenting your injuries, medical expenses, lost wages, and other accident-related losses. Avoid making speculative statements, discussing fault on social media, or accepting a settlement before understanding the extent of your injuries.

Most personal injury lawsuits in Washington are subject to a three-year statute of limitations under RCW 4.16.080. Exceptions may apply, and requesting a police report correction generally does not pause this deadline.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Correct a Police Report After Filing an Insurance Claim?

Yes, you may request a police report correction even after opening an insurance claim. Contact the investigating law enforcement agency and provide evidence supporting the requested changes. If an updated report becomes available, send it to the insurance adjuster and ask for a review of the information.

What If the Police Officer Refuses to Change My Accident Report?

You may be able to request a supplemental report or ask whether the police department offers another review process. You can also provide photographs, witness statements, and other independent evidence directly to the insurance company. An unchanged police report does not automatically prevent you from pursuing a personal injury claim.

What If the Police Report Says I Was Not Injured?

Some car accident injuries, including whiplash, concussions, and soft tissue injuries, may not be immediately apparent. Seek medical attention if symptoms develop and keep records of your diagnosis and treatment. Medical documentation may help establish that your injuries resulted from the collision, even if the original police report did not identify them.

How Long Do I Have to Correct a Police Accident Report in Washington?

Correction procedures and applicable time requirements may vary by law enforcement agency. Contact the investigating department promptly after discovering an error to learn about its policies. Acting quickly may also improve your chances of preserving evidence before recordings are deleted or witnesses become unavailable.

Can I Recover Compensation if the Police Report Says I Caused the Accident?

Yes, you may still have a claim if independent evidence establishes that another party was wholly or partly responsible. Washington’s comparative fault rules allow injured people to recover reduced compensation even when they share responsibility for a collision. An attorney can review the police report and other evidence to determine whether the assigned fault is supported.

Protect Your Car Accident Claim With McNeese & Trotsky, PLLC

An inaccurate police report should not prevent you from seeking compensation for injuries caused by another driver’s negligence. Our attorneys can investigate your collision, identify errors in accident documentation, gather independent evidence, and challenge unfair insurance company findings. If you were injured in Bellevue, Seattle, or elsewhere in Washington, call McNeese & Trotsky, PLLC, at (206) 332-1918 or contact us online for a free consultation to discuss your claim.

CONTACT US

Schedule a Free Consultation

YOUR RECOVERY COMES FIRST.

WE HANDLE THE REST.

If you’ve been injured and aren’t sure what to do next, the Washington personal injury attorneys at McNeese & Trotsky are here to help. We offer free, no-obligation consultations to review your case and explain your options. Contact our Bellevue office today and take the first step toward protecting your rights and your future.

SERIOUS SITUATIONS

NEED SERIOUS REPRESENTATION!

Due to deadlines for filing injury claims, it is critical that you meet with an attorney as soon as possible to evaluate your case.